What controversy? Mosley earned the title

Search

New member
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
520
Tokens
What controversy? Mosley earned the title

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
By Tim Struby
Special to ESPN.com


Redemption, they called it, and redemption it was.


Super Fights in Las Vegas always attracts a bold-type crowd, and Saturday's sellout was no exception. There was Magic and Tiger, Ashton and Demi, Lennox and Kobe (both of whom were greeted with a less-than-small smattering of boos). It was all pomp and pageantry at the MGM -- flesh flashing, jewels shimmering, and an L.A.-esque crowd there to witness two bold-type names themselves, Shane and Oscar.

Yet there was not the ravenous, bloodthirsty air that swirls around certain fights, such as Tyson-Holyfield II or De La Hoya-Vargas, but more of an energetic, expectant vibe that you find at the Super Bowl (with the flair and fashion of a Mary J. Blige concert). It had much to do with the combatants themselves -- paradigms of class and respect, practitioners at the utmost level of the sport.

Predictions? The swarms of boxing experts on hand sounded like a bunch of economists -- nobody was sure of an answer.

"I think it's going to be a draw," said ESPN's Max Kellerman, merely proving how tough it was to forecast a winner.

Their immense respect for one another kept the action slow at the start, but by the fourth round, the two fighters worked carefully and craftily, slipping and shooting, like maestros conducting a symphony in the ring. The crowd got impatient at times, and even a vigilant Joe Cortez prompted them to mix it up as the action waned.

"Give 'em the business, baby!" yelled actor Larenz Tate to Mosley.

According to all three judges, Mosley did just that with a 115-113 victory.

There was no scent of foul play, unfair treatment, but only of a closely fought bout.

For Oscar, the future is uncertain.

"I think he'll retire," former HBO guru Lou DiBella said. "He's a man of his word."

That's what he pledged to do, yet it's easier said than done. For the biggest draw and one of the biggest talents, it will be tough to forgo the adulation, and tougher to give up what he does best.

And the Golden Boy is HBO's Golden Goose, and he has a myriad of options considering his performance did not tarnish his luster (yet there was a much ballyhooed stink on HBO that he did in fact win the fight). There are millions still out there for him in the form of a Vargas rematch, a Bernard Hopkins bout, and even a third attempt to rid himself of the monkey on his back in the shape of Shane Mosley.

As for Mosley, the victory is certainly redemptive. It has resuscitated a career that, a day ago, was a 2½-to-1 bet that salad days were over. Vernon Forrest merely had his number, much like he clearly has De La Hoya's. Options are aplenty, too. On the horizon lie Vargas and a promise to top challenger Winkie Wright. And although he will never garner the purses the Golden Boy brings in, Mosley ran relish the notion that in a matter of 36 minutes he has rebuilt a career and a life. And just in case he doubts it, he can just listen to the cheers of the bold-type names at ringside. He has won them all back.

Tim Struby is a contributor for ESPN The Magazine.

http://msn.espn.go.com/boxing/s/2003/0913/1615580.html

[This message was edited by Boxing Freak on September 14, 2003 at 02:16 PM.]
 

New member
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
520
Tokens
This was indeed a close fight. And these judges happened to be on the same page in terms of how to go about scoring a fight. Apparently they were impressed by Shane's aggressiveness and not by Oscar's retreating throughout the bout.

In all honesty, I think that this is getting blown all out of proportion because Oscar is a fan-favorite and infinitely more popular than Shane. Had this not been the case, I do not think that we would be talking so much about "controversy".
 

New member
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
96
Tokens
I finally won one of these "controversies."
icon_biggrin.gif
 

New member
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
520
Tokens
Mosley is deserving of win
Mosley win is hardly shocking

By Doug Krikorian
Sports columnist


LAS VEGAS -- A most surprising occurrence unfolded here Saturday night Oscar De La Hoya lost a fight he, most of his loyal followers and the HBO broadcasting team thought he won.

And Sugar Shane Mosley won in a manner few people thought would be possible for him emerging with a unanimous decision against boxing's most glamorous fistic attraction.

No one thought that would happen because, after all, Bob Arum's Top Rank organization promoted this fight and De La Hoya figured to have all the political edges with the judges.

But that didn't turn out to be the case, and I think the judges, Stanley Christodoulou, Anek Hontongkam and Duane Ford had it right in all scoring it 115-113 for Mosley.

Indeed, I had Mosley even a bigger winner at 117-113, as I thought he landed almost all the explosive punches in a fight that did not live up to its billing, as neither man performed in a manner that would inspire comparisons to some of their legendary predecessors.

There was nothing that happened throughout the 12 rounds that will make a lasting imprint on the memories of the 16,268 spectators who saw Mosley relentlessly pursue a retreating, counter- punching De La Hoya from almost the opening bell and saw only a few brisk exchanges that evoked cheers.

But these same folk were booing after an eighth round that was bereft of action, as neither man seemed inclined to mix it up both men feinted too often in this one even though they were encouraged to do so by the referee, Joe Cortez.

"I definitely thought I won,' said De La Hoya, who certainly didn't look like a winner afterward with a bruised right cheek and cut right eye that was caused by a Mosley butt in the fourth round.

"I thought I won a close decision,' said Mosley, who had De La Hoya badly hurt in the ninth round with a jarring left hook and also stunned him in the final one with a wicked right hand.

Not once did De La Hoya have Mosley reeling, although those computerized punch stats the most overrated numbers in boxing had him well ahead in this category, claiming he connected on 221 punches to 127 for Mosley.

I could care less what the punch stats insisted, but my eyes saw Sugar Shane Mosley defy the critics I mistakenly thought he was over-the-hill and wouldn't pose a serious challenge to De La Hoya and I saw him land the most lethal punches and I saw him winning eight rounds.

Apparently, Jim Lampley, George Foreman, Larry Merchant and Harold Letterman, the HBO crew, didn't see it that way, and I respect all of their opinions.

And I also know that Oscar De La Hoya is HBO's most lucrative boxing client, and that these fellows just might have subconsciously viewed this fight through the perspective of De La Hoya, instead of looking at the damage that Mosley was administering.

I could care less who won I certainly would have looked like a shrewder forecaster had De La Hoya emerged victorious and was surprised that the outcome was so controversial.

So were my sportswriting brethren, an overwhelming majority of whom had Mosley dethroning De La Hoya in this WBA/WBC super welterweight title fight.

As is customary in fights of this magnitude, there were all sorts of intriguing developments leading up to it, including the emergence to center stage this past week of a species, ticket scalpers, that had been on the threshold of extinction in the sport.

Indeed, these beleaguered fellows hadn't done brisk business at fights in these parts since June of 1997, when Evander Holyfield and Mike Tyson duked it out in their second notorious meeting.

But, oh, did they have a comeback in this one, as they inflated the price of tickets as if this were the Super Bowl, reportedly getting as much as $10,000 for $1,200 ringsides in the first few rows.

"If I knew this fight was going to take off like this, I'd have priced ringside tickets at $2,000,' said Bob Arum.

Dozens of professional scalpers were seen at the MGM Grand on Saturday afternoon, peddling their wares, searching desperately for tickets as the demand for them far exceeded the supply, much to the glee of Arum and the MGM hierarchy, which paid out a $9.1 million site fee.

The Mosley camp, via its promoter, Gary Shaw, sort of a ham-and-cheese version of Bob Arum, also caused a stir on Thursday when they claimed De La Hoya has been wearing a cup with an oversized protective girdle that Shaw felt was too protective of De La Hoya's body.

Marc Ratner, chairman of the Nevada State Athletic Commission, and his minions checked it out and, shockingly, they found nothing illegal. I say shockingly because De La Hoya could probably could have worn football pads and a bulletproof vest into a ring in Nevada, where he's a cash cow for the economy, and no one would object except, of course, those aligned against him in the opposite corner.

But Oscar De La Hoya wasn't given the benefit of the doubt by the officials this time in what turned out to be the most shocking thing about this fight, and now has to hand over an extra $500,000 to Mosley as sort of a reward for his overcoming the 2 1/2-to-1 odds and perhaps his guilt for earning so much more than Mosley.

De La Hoya was guaranteed $12 million a percentage from brisk pay-per- view sales figures to up his final sum to $17 million while Mosley was put on bread and water at $4.5 million.

But Sugar Shane Mosley was the one who wound up smiling and having his hand raised here Saturday night, while De La Hoya and Bob Arum were calling this a Brinks Robbery, or Evander Holyfield-Lennox Lewis I.

I disagree.

Deservedly, Sugar Shane Mosley got the nod of the judges, who didn't turn out to be as bias as De La Hoya and Arum and the HBO people, much to the amazement of almost everybody.

The McDonnell-Douglas Show, featuring Press-Telegram columnist Doug Krikorian and radio personality Joe McDonnell, can be heard Monday through Friday between 3 p.m. and 7 p.m. on ESPN radio, KSPN 710 AM

http://www.presstelegram.com/Stories/0,1413,204~28780~1631238,00.html
 

New member
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
617
Tokens
Mosely flat out lost that fight. He didn't earn anything.
 

New member
Joined
Sep 20, 2004
Messages
1,991
Tokens
it`s funny.....for every article you put up rationalizing the decision,you can easily put up one with an alternative opinion.....

it seems where dlh is concerned,there are some serious haters out there....i read a couple scribes that kept referring to the "dlh lovers".....it`s sad when people can`t be objective....since when does having a press credential make you objective?.....or a license to judge fights for that matter.....i don`t think i can ever remember hearing more guys that won money on a fight(myself and almly included),thinking they got a gift....

fights are scored on a round by round basis...not by how decisively you win a round....but by WHO wins the round...each round is exclusive...it has nothing to do with who finishes stronger....unless it`s in vegas....

anybody that thinks that mosely won 7 rounds in that fight has a problem...he did virtually nothing for the first 7 rounds....and 2 judges had him winning the last 5 rounds....

i don`t think so....

whatever...everybody`s entitled to their own opinion....

just keep wondering why jack mosely was imploring shane to stop oscar if he wanted to win the fight...and shane`s incredulous look when the decision was announced....

lol...
 

New member
Joined
Sep 21, 2004
Messages
520
Tokens
<BLOCKQUOTE class="ip-ubbcode-quote"><font size="-1">quote:</font><HR>Originally posted by sphincter:
just keep wondering why jack mosely was imploring shane to stop oscar if he wanted to win the fight...and shane`s incredulous look when the decision was announced....lol...<HR></BLOCKQUOTE>

So you noticed that look of surprise also? That was pretty amusing.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
1,120,310
Messages
13,580,156
Members
100,962
Latest member
habibroshan0
The RX is the sports betting industry's leading information portal for bonuses, picks, and sportsbook reviews. Find the best deals offered by a sportsbook in your state and browse our free picks section.FacebookTwitterInstagramContact Usforum@therx.com